Golf course and mountain views under a clouded sky at Desert Mountain

Private, Semi-Private or Public: Choosing a Golf Community in Scottsdale

One of the first things to sort out when choosing a golf community in Scottsdale is who gets to play the course. A private club, a semi-private club and a public course can sit a few miles apart and feel like different worlds. I spent years working inside private clubs before I became a Realtor, and this is how I explain the difference.

Private clubs

At a private club, you play as a member or as a member’s guest. Desert Mountain, Silverleaf, Estancia, Whisper Rock and Mirabel are all private. Expect an initiation fee, monthly dues and often a food and beverage minimum. In return, you get staff who know your name and a built-in group of people to play with. Private clubs do get busy in season, but you are sharing the tee sheet with other members, not competing with the public for a tee time or waiting behind them on pace of play.

Living in the community does not always mean belonging to the club. That is such a common question that I wrote a separate article on it.

Semi-private clubs

A semi-private club has members and also sells tee times to the public. Troon North is the best-known example here, with two courses open to daily-fee play and a membership on top. You can live near a well-known course without joining, though it will be busier than a private club, especially in season, and memberships can come with a waitlist.

Some clubs split the difference with a resort. The Boulders, on the Scottsdale and Carefree line, and Ventana Canyon in Tucson each have two courses shared between members and resort or outside play. Typically, members have one course on a given day while outside play runs on the other, and how the courses rotate is worth asking about.

Public courses

At a public course, anyone can book a tee time and there is no membership to join. Grayhawk and Legend Trail are good examples. This often suits people who play a couple of times a month, or who like the look of a golf course out the back window without the dues that come with a club.

These communities can also cost less to get into. Over the past year, the median home sold for about $775,000 in Grayhawk and about $5.15 million in Silverleaf, based on ARMLS data. That is a wide gap, and the type of club is only part of the reason.

A note on player cards

If you play public or resort golf often, look into player cards. Some golf course management companies offer them for better rates during the winter, and the savings can add up quickly. The trade-off is that you may get less favorable tee times or be able to book less far in advance, which can leave your plans more up in the air. Read the terms before you count on one for January through March.

How to decide when choosing a golf community

  • How often will you really play? A few rounds a week can justify a membership. A few rounds a month usually does not.
  • Do you want the club or just the course? Dining, fitness, tennis and a social calendar are a big part of what private members pay for.
  • Will you be here all year? Seasonal owners should ask about non-resident options and what dues look like while they are away.
  • What is the full monthly number? Add club dues, food minimums and HOA dues together before you compare homes.
  • How easy is it to get in? Some clubs have waitlists, and some memberships are tied to the home.

There is often a middle ground

You do not have to choose between full golf and nothing. Many private clubs offer social or sports memberships, and some let you move up later if a spot is available. I walk through the types in golf memberships explained.

Quick answers

What is the difference between a private and a semi-private golf club?

A private club is limited to members and their guests. A semi-private club has members but also sells tee times to the public.

Are there public golf communities in Scottsdale?

Yes. Grayhawk and Legend Trail are built around public courses, so there is no membership to join in order to play.

Do you have to join the club to live in a Scottsdale golf community?

Not always. It depends on the community, and some private clubs are tied more closely to the homes than others, so confirm the rules for the specific home.

If you are weighing a few communities, tell me how you like to play and I will help you narrow them down. The golf community guides are a good place to start.

Abby Burton, Realtor with Keller Williams Arizona Realty

Written by Abby Burton

Abby is a Realtor with Keller Williams Arizona Realty and a former PGA Class A Golf Professional who spent years inside high-end private clubs, including Desert Mountain Golf Club. She helps buyers and sellers across Scottsdale, with a specialty in golf communities. More about Abby or start a conversation.

Not looking in a golf community? Here is how I can help.

FREE GUIDE

The Scottsdale Golf Community Guide

Twenty-six communities compared side by side, with current market numbers and club costs. Sent to your inbox as a PDF.